Skip to content

Service

ORX Scenarios

Community

ORX Scenarios Community

Risk programme

Management, Practice & Framework

Benchmark - June 2024

Covering the end-to-end scenario process and the changing uses of operational risk scenario analysis, the ORX Scenarios 2024 Scenario Process Benchmark and Research Study investigates current industry maturity and future enhancement plans.

It's the largest benchmarking and practice dataset ever collected by ORX Scenarios, with nearly 90 financial institutions taking part.


 

Bank_Lime

75

Banks

ThreeBuildingLime

14

Insurers


 

Survey methodology

The dataset was collected through a three-part survey of scenario processes and practices including: 

 

 

Part 1

A benchmarking survey of current scenario process maturity enabling granular self-assessments against the industry and peers based on a new maturity matrix.

Scenarios Reversed_Lime

 

 

Part 2

A process and use survey designed to understand why and how institutions are optimising their scenario process to serve new scenario uses and purposes, including risk management.

Scenarios Reversed_Lime

Part 3

A scenario template collection exercise to support ORX’s plan to develop industry standard scenario documentation.

Scenarios Reversed_Lime

Outputs from the survey

  • Individual benchmark reports: comparing participating institutions’ maturity scores to the rest of the industry and segmenting them by sector, region and size (sent directly to participating institutions).
  • Peer benchmark reports: comparing participating institutions’ maturity scores to selected peer institutions (issued on request and sent directly to participating institutions).
  • A summary benchmark report: available for ORX Scenarios subscribers to download below. This provides an overview of total industry maturity broken down by sector, region and size.
  • The Scenario Process Maturity Matrix: also available to download below and used to support the benchmarking self-assessment. 
  • State of the Industry report: published after the initial outputs in October 2024. This paper provides insight into the industry’s main scenario process enhancement priorities along with practical evidence-based options for scenario leaders and practitioners to consider as they work to optimise and unlock the full potential of their scenario programme. Download the State of the Industry white paper.
  • Scenarios for Risk Management report: also published in October 2024. This report provides an overview of uses, benefits, and process implications of scenarios. Download the Scenarios for Risk Management report.

How to use the benchmark reports

Participants’ individual and peer benchmark reports can be used to: 

  • Assess and compare the maturity of each stage of your end-to-end scenario process against the industry as a whole, institutions in your sector, institutions in your region, institutions of a similar size, and (if requested) peer institutions.
  • Identify and inform scenario process enhancement priorities and initiatives at relevant process stages, including scenario identification and selection, trigger use and processes, scenario review and refresh practices, qualitative development, quantitative assessment, scenario integration, systems, and process automation.
  • Report scenario process enhancement needs to senior management by highlighting key process weaknesses to inform strategic planning and prioritisation.
  • Monitor and evidence progress and developments in your scenario process over time against your current maturity scores using the ORX Scenarios Maturity Matrix.   

Gated content start

Gated content stop

Contacts:

Helen L’Abbate

Helen L’Abbate

Deputy Director - Research & Information, ORX

Simon Johnson

Simon Johnson

Head of Services, ORX

Robert Reay-Jones

Robert Reay-Jones

Scenarios Senior Manager, ORX

Mia Davies

Mia Davies

Junior Research Analyst, ORX